Money. Time. Energy. These are all essential resources your nonprofit pours into acquiring new donors. Your team crafts compelling marketing materials, hosts memorable events, and launches engaging fundraising campaigns throughout the year. But considering 70% of donors never give again after their first transaction, how do you make it all worth the effort?

It’s not enough to inspire donors to give once. By nurturing strong, lasting relationships with donors, you can secure larger gifts, expand your reach, and ultimately unlock new levels of support to advance your mission.

Let’s walk through five best practices your nonprofit can use to enhance its communications and build a loyal donor base it can rely on for years to come.

1. Create personalized donor experiences.

Successful relationships are two-way streets. While it’s important for your nonprofit to educate donors about your mission, programs, and impact, it’s equally important that you learn about your donors. By maintaining in-depth donor profiles, you can apply a more data-driven approach to marketing and outreach.

Make donors feel individually valued by tailoring your messages to them. Segment donors based on key characteristics to ensure that they receive only the most relevant communications from your nonprofit. Some common ways to segment your donors include:

• Age
• Geographic Location
• Interests
• Average Gift Size
• Donation Frequency

Beyond personalizing your messages, consider providing various flexible giving options so donors can get involved in the ways they most prefer. For example, create a “Ways to Give” page on your website (like this one from Lift Up the Vulnerable) that explains how donors can support your nonprofit through recurring gifts, donor-advised funds, stock donations, and legacy giving.

2. Don’t always ask for donations.

While you should keep donors informed about your nonprofit’s fundraising needs, too many appeals can lead to donor fatigue, where donors start decreasing their giving upon feeling overwhelmed or burned out.

There are plenty of ways you can connect with donors beyond repeatedly asking them to give. NPOInfo recommends inviting donors to attend events, such as a facility tour, to help them feel more connected to your work and see the firsthand impact of their support. Additionally, you can encourage donors to:

• Subscribe to your email newsletter.
• Join your social media community.
• Check out your blog.
• Create user-generated content related to your mission.
• Sign a petition.
• Become a volunteer.

Rather than talking at your donors, engage in two-way conversations by responding to their questions and comments on social media. You can even build a text contact list and allow subscribers to communicate directly with a representative of your nonprofit.

3. Maintain strong, consistent branding.

A well-presented brand demonstrates that your nonprofit is professional, reliable, and confident in its mission. According to Liminal’s nonprofit branding guide, incorporating clear and consistent branding across your communications allows you to:

• Build trust and credibility. When donors see your messages and content, they’ll automatically know that it’s coming from your nonprofit and feel more comfortable acting on whatever you’re asking them to do.
• Create alignment. By encapsulating your organization’s mission, values, and identity in your branding, you make it easier for donors to understand what your organization stands for. The more aligned they are with your goals, the more likely they are to continue supporting you.
• Raise more funds. A distinctive and compelling brand allows your nonprofit to stand out from others in the sector, helping you catch the attention of current and prospective donors.
• Inspire engagement. Through effective branding, you can turn your nonprofit from an organization into a community, weaving more emotional connections between donors and your mission to boost engagement over time.
• Navigate change. The nonprofit sector is always shifting with new opportunities and challenges. No matter what lies ahead, a strong brand identity provides clarity for both your organization and its donors moving forward.

Develop official brand guidelines that outline instructions for logo usage, storytelling, voice, and tone. Share this document with your staff and volunteers to ensure that they can represent your nonprofit with consistency and accuracy.

4. Focus on transparency.

When people donate to your nonprofit, they trust that you’ll put their dollars to good use. It’s up to you to prove to them that their trust was well placed.

Independent Sector reports that 80% of Americans need to see proof of an organization’s impact to continue supporting it. Use these tips to enhance transparency in your communications with donors:

• Specify the impact of suggested donation amounts. Adding suggested giving amounts to your donation page can inspire more generosity from donors who aren’t sure how much they want to contribute. Help them visualize the impact of their donation by highlighting what it will help accomplish. For example, an education-focused nonprofit might explain that a $25 donation will provide a young student with one new book per month for a year.
• Tell authentic, meaningful stories. Facts and figures can make your impact more concrete, but stories are what linger in people’s minds. Reach out to your beneficiaries and volunteers for permission to share their stories with your donors. Consider producing blog posts and video interviews with eye-catching visuals to spark empathy and connection in your audience.
• Share your financial information. By publishing your financial statements and policies on your nonprofit’s website, you can demonstrate to donors that your organization is financially healthy and responsible. Consider using charts and graphs to illustrate key information, such as your program expense ratio, so donors can better understand how you allocate resources.

Keep donors updated on your accomplishments, but don’t shy away from discussing any challenges you’re facing, too. By being open and honest, you come across as more accountable and improvement-driven to donors, who may even have a few suggestions or ideas to help you out.

5. Practice frequent donor recognition.

Imagine you went out of your way to help a friend pack up and prepare for a move across the country. But when the time came, they left without even a word of thanks. While you were happy to help, they certainly didn’t leave you feeling appreciated as a friend, and you might not be as enthusiastic the next time they need help.

Your donors can feel the same way if you don’t follow up after their gift. While an automatic donation acknowledgment email is a start, consider incorporating a variety of ideas into your recognition strategy—tailoring them to each donor’s giving level. For example, you could express your appreciation through:

• Social media shoutouts
• Animated eCards
• Thank-you phone calls or videos
• Free branded merchandise
• Digital donor walls
• Donor appreciation events

Consider automating birthday wishes and celebrating each donor’s milestones with your nonprofit, such as their third year of giving, to show them that you’re paying attention.

Beyond saying “thank you” to donors, you can send surveys to collect their feedback and understand how to improve their experience with your organization in the future. Staying tuned into your donors' expectations and preferences allows you to build and maintain strong relationships that will power your mission year after year.

For example, your donors might share that your website is challenging to navigate, and they’re confused about how your programs contribute to your overall mission. In response, you might partner with a nonprofit branding agency to revamp your online experience and clarify your messaging to strengthen donors’ connection to your organization.

‍